Brighton's man-to-man defence underpins strong Premier League start
Brighton's hybrid man-to-man defensive approach, combining high pressing with a plus-one at the back, has powered their rise to third place and wins over Manchester City and Arsenal.
Brighton sit third in the Premier League, behind only Manchester City and leaders Arsenal, having beaten both this season. Their 1-0 win over City followed a Carabao Cup exit to the same opponents, and it marked the first time City had failed to score at home in 23 matches. With 24 goals in nine games Brighton are the league's top scorers, but their defensive work has underpinned the results against the strongest sides: they have conceded just seven goals, with only Arsenal letting in fewer.
From opposition goal-kicks Brighton press high and man-to-man with an intensity that makes them better at it than most. Because the opposition keeper gives the defending team an extra passing option against Brighton's 10 outfielders, one attacker curves their run toward the keeper, cutting off the angle back to the centre-back they have left, while teammates pick up their direct opponents. Brighton also accept leaving a player unmarked when that player is far from the ball, such as a full-back or winger on the opposite side, judging the extra pressing body nearer the ball to be worth the risk.
What makes Brighton unusual is that they keep man-to-man ideas when defending deeper, rather than settling into a rigid zonal block such as a 4-4-2. If opponents commit four forwards high, Brighton defend with five, maintaining a 'plus-one' in the backline while prioritising protection of the central areas. Against City, Enzo Maresca pushed right-back Matheus Nunes infield into a striker-like position, a tactic also used by Paris St-Germain and Arsenal; Maxim de Cuyper, a left-back by trade deployed as a left winger, tracked Nunes and ended up defending at left centre-back, forming a back five before returning to the wing in possession.
The spare player is usually an opposition centre-back, who can have time on the ball. Brighton's shifting structure is designed to keep every passing option marked or capable of being marked within a fraction of a second, and to spring forward to press the unmarked centre-back, at which point they lock into a full man-to-man press. Abdukodir Khusanov's powerful ball-carrying from a wider position was perhaps City's best solution. Supporters have taken note of the approach without necessarily treating it as a guarantee of continued success; their optimism is opinion rather than a verified outcome.
Image: Getty Images / BBC Sport
