Premier League board in focus as Manchester City sanction phase begins
After an independent commission found Manchester City guilty of breaching financial rules, the Premier League board will recommend a sanction, but the final decision rests with the commission and City maintain their innocence and have appealed.
An independent commission's finding that Manchester City breached financial rules has moved the case into a sanction phase, with the Premier League board responsible for recommending a punishment. The three-person commission will ultimately decide any sanction, weighing the league's submission alongside City's position; the club maintains its innocence and has appealed. No date for a sanction hearing has been set, and possible outcomes include a fine, points deduction, expulsion or the stripping of past titles.
The board comprises chair Alison Brittain, chief executive Richard Masters and three independent non-executive directors, with no club representatives, a structure intended to provide independence and neutrality. Brittain, the league's first female chair, was reappointed unanimously by the 20 clubs in 2025. Masters said the commission's core decision vindicated the league's decision to pursue the case and that the board applies rules consistently regardless of the club involved.
The non-executive directors are Mai Fyfield, a former Sky executive who led bidding for three Premier League television cycles; Dharmash Mistry, a technology venture capitalist who chairs the league's audit and finance committee and represents it on the FA board; and Matthew Ryder, a senior barrister, part-time judge and former deputy mayor of London who chairs the league's legal advisory group. The Premier League declined to comment when approached by BBC Sport.
Past disciplinary cases show commissions do not always follow the board's recommendations. In 2023 the league argued for a 12-point sanction for Everton, but the commission imposed 10, later reduced to six on appeal. In 2024 the league suggested eight points for Nottingham Forest, and the commission settled on four. This year the league argued for a 12-point deduction for Leicester City in the Championship, while the commission recommended six points to be imposed by the EFL.
There is also an alternative to contested proceedings. Earlier this year the board reached a sanctions agreement with Chelsea resulting in a £10m fine and a suspended transfer ban after the club admitted secret payments to unregistered agents and third parties. The league cited Chelsea's self-reporting, admissions and cooperation as significant mitigating factors.
Image: Getty Images / BBC Sport
