Trafford's Madrid heroics reignite England goalkeeper debate
All news / Football

Trafford's Madrid heroics reignite England goalkeeper debate

James Trafford's late double save in England's 3-2 win over Spain has intensified discussion over whether he should displace Jordan Pickford as Thomas Tuchel's first-choice goalkeeper.

BETAIGO EditorialUpdated:

James Trafford delivered a standout performance as England beat world champions Spain 3-2 in Madrid, a result that handed the hosts their first defeat in 43 matches. On his fifth cap, the 24-year-old Leeds goalkeeper made four key saves in the final 12 minutes, including a double stop to deny Lamine Yamal and then Fermin Lopez from close range, after which his team-mates mobbed him.

The display sharpened a question Tuchel had addressed only last week, when he described Everton's Jordan Pickford as his number one. After full-time in Spain, however, Tuchel told ITV Sport there was "no number one" and called Trafford's showing brilliant. Trafford has rotated with Pickford across England's five matches since the World Cup, starting both games against Spain while Pickford featured against Czech Republic and Croatia.

Reaction from within the game was emphatic. Declan Rice highlighted the speed of the double save as a massive night for Trafford, while Spain coach Luis de la Fuente said England's goalkeeper had stopped two or three potential goals in the closing stages. Former Manchester United captain Roy Keane described Tuchel's rotation as smart management and the ideal opportunity for Trafford to prove himself against top players.

The case for Trafford rests on form as well as that night in Madrid. He ranks first among goalkeepers with at least 10 games in Europe's big five leagues this season by save percentage, at 81.4%, and his club moves have made him England's most expensive goalkeeper by transfer fee twice. Many supporters on social media have suggested the performance marked a changing of the guard, though that remains opinion rather than established fact.

Pickford's claim is longevity. The 32-year-old has won 94 caps since his 2017 debut and, according to Opta, has made only two errors leading to goals for England, with 46 clean sheets and a 74.3% save ratio. Former England goalkeeper Paul Robinson told BBC Sport before the Spain match that Pickford rightly remains first choice on consistency, though he acknowledged a future conversation is inevitable. Whether Trafford starts England's Nations League quarter-finals is a decision only Tuchel can make.

Source: BBC Sport

Image: Getty Images / BBC Sport

BETAIGO / iOS & ANDROID

Your next match. A new perspective.

Take the statistics, the analysis and the conversation with you. BETAIGO is available for iOS and Android.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
BETAIGO matchday on your phone
More on this story below